"I wanted to say a huge thank you to Simon Bonner who has just helped me secure my new role. He was one of the most professional recruiters I have ever worked with"
Julia Marcinkiewicz
How to Answer the Interview Question About When You Have Made a Mistake
The dreaded making a mistake question
Why sales interviewers ask about failure
Typically, interviews focus on the candidate's key achievements, experience, competencies, and performance against targets or KPIs, all of which are valid and positive indicators of their suitability for the job.
However, many organisations also value introspection and the ability to identify and learn from mistakes. In particular, in sales, where resilience and the ability to 'bounce back' is a prerequisite
Demonstrating this gives insight into an individual's ability to analyse, overcome ego or unconscious bias, and strive for improvement and personal development, which ultimately benefits both the individual and the employer.
For this purpose, a commonly asked question is “Describe a time when you failed at a task or made a mistake”.
Turn a mistake into an opportunity
Although frequently used, this question can be problematic if not prepared for, as it invites us to disclose an apparent negative experience in a job interview where we want to present our best self.
With a little preparation, however, this is a perfect opportunity to showcase a range of your positive qualities.
Example answer: learning from a missed sales target
Let’s consider an instance where a candidate in an interview discloses that they failed to hit an important financial target by some distance –
Candidate - “In 2023 I achieved 102% of the revenue target, but in 2024 I only achieved 82% and missed out on my bonus. I was confused and disappointed, so I decided to run some analysis of my performance to understand where things had gone wrong.
From our CRM, it became apparent that my sales volume was consistent, and in fact there was a small increase in 2023. However, due to cheaper imports from overseas competitors, my profit margin was lower where I competed for large-volume orders. I also shifted my focus to selling more inexpensive products to compete on price.
As a result, both my average order value and profit margins dropped significantly, causing me to miss target even though I was working as hard as ever.
To compensate, I calculated that I needed to increase my daily call rate by 10%, from 50 to 55, to hit the required revenue figure. However, I also sought retraining on the features and benefits of our premium product range so I could sell on quality, not price, and avoid being dragged into a “race to the bottom”.
As a result, my profit margin increased significantly, exceeding my 2023 performance, and in 2025 I achieved 124% of target, earning all of my available bonus and winning a trip to Barcelona.
I now monitor my revenue and margin numbers throughout the year to ensure they are tracking at least 100% of target."
By answering the question this way, you turn a negative outcome into multiple positive experiences, all of which will benefit your prospective new employer: introspection, accountability for your own performance, analysis, persistence, determination, and planning and strategising for future success, to name only a few.
Structure your answer with the STAR method
This answer utilises the STAR method, which is a technique for structuring answers to interview questions by describing a specific Situation, the Task you had to complete, the Action you took, and the Result of your actions, hence S.T.A.R.
It helps provide clear, concise, and evidence-based examples of your skills and experience. You can prepare for interviews by using the STAR method to practice answering questions about past challenges and accomplishments.
More information on preparing answers to questions in this way can be found here-
Search jobs
With hundreds of jobs available, now is the time to look for your perfect position
Please call us to discuss your next move
From our blog
Our employers say...
Our candidates say...